5 facts about immigration and women – International Women’s Day

Caritas International Belgium 5 facts about immigration and women – International Women’s Day

One in three migrant women are overqualified for their job, compared to less than one in six native men. Without a doubt we have a long way to go in terms of equality!

One in three migrant women are overqualified for their job, compared to less than one in six native men. Without a doubt we have a long way to go in terms of equality!

06/03/2020

Do women migrate as much as men? And for what reasons? What is their place in the job market in Belgium? So many questions to be addressed on this day, March 8th, which is International Women’s Day. The answer to these questions is summed up in five facts about migration.

In the collective imagination, international immigration is mainly composed of men. However, the statistics show a completely different reality. Nearly half of the immigrant population in Belgium are women.[1][2][3]

FACT 1: Nearly half of the immigrant population in Belgium are women 

UNDERESTIMATION OF FEMALE MIGRATION

This false perception of the proportion of migrant women is the result of various factors that are hard to distinguish from each other. One of the possible reasons for this stereotype is that in the aftermath of World War Two, migrants were heavily recruited form mining and steel industries and they were exclusively men.

Another possibility is that the proportion of migrant men has slightly increased over the past two decades following the accession of several countries such as Poland, Romania and Bulgaria to the European Union in 2004. Also, the arrival of mostly male refugees seeking international protection (72% in 2015).[4] This overrepresentation of men may be explained by the fact that many of them decide to go to Europe alone and bring the rest of their family later via family reunification. The statistics for family reunification confirm that it is an essential pathway for women; 65% of the family reunification visa applications concern women.[5]

FACT 2: Family reunification is an essential entry pathway for women.     

The story of 49-year-old Marwane and his family illustrates this reality. He risked his life to flee Syria and come to Europe in the hope that he could then bring his wife and two sons. In 2018, his dream came true.

WHY DO THEY MIGRATE?

The reasons why men and women leave also vary. According to the reason for the first residence permit, women represent 72% of the migrants who arrived in Belgium for family reasons, 50% for reasons related to education, and 34% for professional reasons.

Women who are in need of international protection may have specific reasons for migrating. These include violence against women in the event of an armed conflict as they have a systematically higher risk of being harmed. Another reason may be structural discrimination, some of which can lead to situations of violence such as forced marriages, genital mutilation, domestic violence etc. Globally, one in two refugees are women (48% in 2018).[6]

FACT 3: One in two refugees are women.  

MIGRANT WOMEN IN THE WORK FORCE?

Employment opportunities for immigrants in Belgium are among the worst in the EU. The employment rate for 20 to 64-year old’s is 53.9%, compared with 72% for natives.[7] Migrant women experience an even lower employment rate than their male counterparts (14.9% difference). There is also a difference of 15.1% for women who are born in Belgium. The employment rate is even lower if you only analyzed migrant women born outside the EU.  emploi est encore plus bas si l’on analyse uniquement les femmes migrant-e-s nées en dehors de l’UE.

 

FACT 4: Female migrants have a lower employment rate than their male counterparts    

There are different reasons that may explain the difference in the employment rate between men and women. Globally women participate less than men in the labor market, this could be due to private family choices or pragmatic aspects. It is sometimes more financially attractive for women to stay at home because childcare is expensive and the wages that women receive are generally lower. Differences in education may explain these wage and employments gaps, but they are insufficient. In fact, one in three migrant women (33.8%) are overqualified for their position compared to one in four migrant men (28.6%).[8] In the case of people born in Belgium, one woman in four is overqualified (21.3%) compared to one man in six (17.9%).

FACT 5: One in three migrant women are overqualified for their job.   

These lower levels of women’s employment and skills are the result of their three identities: migrant, women… and a migrant woman. Similar to their male counterparts, migrant women face administrative difficulties (recognition of diploma and skills etc.), language acquisition and discrimination. In addition, there are often specific barriers that women face such as childcare, gender inequality, stereotypes etc.

>> ALSO READ: Chapter 3 of the report,  “Designing a common home: migration and development in Belgium”

SHE SHARES HER EXPERIENCE…

To conclude, let’s give the floor to Ruchika who is originally from India but she moved to Belgium five years ago:

Caritas International Belgium 5 facts about immigration and women – International Women’s Day


This article is written within the framework of the MIND project, which receives financial support from the European Union’s Development Education and Awareness Programme (DEAR). The contents are the responsibility of Caritas International and do not necessarily reflect the views of the European Union.

Caritas International Belgium 5 facts about immigration and women – International Women’s Day



[1]

Statbel – Directorate General Statistics. Abdeslam Marfouk’s calculations.

[2]

The proportion of migrants varies little from one region of origin to another. In 2017, women represented 56% of migrants from the Americas, 52% from Europe, 49% from Asia, 49% from Africa and 48% from Oceania. Source: Statbel- Directorate General Statistics. Abdeslam Marfouk’s calculations.

[3]

Une analyse pays par pays montre certaines variations plus prononcées. La migration de Russie, du Canada et de Guinée est par exemple majoritairement féminine – les femmes représentaient respectivement 63%, 60% et 59 % de la migration en 2015. A contrario, la migration d’Erythrée et de Roumanie est majoritairement masculine (respectivement 85 % et 65 % des migrants). Source : Myria, “La migration a-t-elle un genre ?“, décembre 2016, consulté le 3 mars 2020.

A country-by-country analysis shows more pronounced variations. Migration from Russia, Canada and Guinea is for example predominantly female – women respectively represented 63%, 60% and 59% of migration in 2015. Conversely, the migration from Eritrea and Romania is predominantly male (respectively 85% and 65% of migrants). Source: Myria, “Does migration have a gender?”(FR) December 2016, accessed March 3, 2020.

[4]

Myria, “Does migration have a gender?”(FR) December 2016, accessed March 3, 2020.

[5]

FPS Foreign Affairs in Myria, “Does migration have a gender?”(FR) December 2016, accessed March 3, 2020.

[6]

UNHCR, “Global Trends. Forced Displacement in 2018,” 2017, accessed March 6, 2018.
Eurostat. Figures for 2018

[7]

Eurostat. 2018 figures.

[8]

OECD/EU, “Indicators of Immigrant Integration,” July 2015. Data from 2012-13.

Linked news

Caritas International Belgium Europe must embrace human mobility

Europe must embrace human mobility

On this International Migrants Day, Caritas Europa highlights the indispensable contribution that migrants make to Europe’s society and economy. In a new briefing paper, we…

Read more
All the news